Monday, June 28, 2010

Graceling

Graceling by Kristin Cashore: Book Cover

Published Information

Author: Kristin Cashore
Series: No series, but several books are in same world
Published: October 2008
Genre: Fantasy
Pages: 480

Ratings

Violence: PG-13 (Talk of torture, detailed fights)
Sexual Content: PG-13 (One specific, but not explicit scene, see below)
Language: PG (Don't recall anything bad)
Reading Age: High school
Buy Recommend: Paperback (Very good but dark, will not re-read)
Overall Rating: 7 out of 10 (Good, believable story, fast paced)

Plot Summary

Graceling takes place in a medieval world where a small group of people are graced. That is, they have a grace that allows them to be experts in some field. And no two graces are alike. Some have fighting graces such as sword fighting, archery, or running incredibly fast. Others have passive graces such mind reading, or weather forecasting. Music, baking, climbing trees, etc, are all skills that can be presented in a grace. And if you have a grace, you are called a graceling and the king has the option to take you into his service in order to use your grace. Lastly, if you are a graceling, each of your eyes are different colors. Your eye color doesn't come at birth, but once the different color eyes manifest themselves, the king will take you into his service until your grace is understood. Then either he enlists you in his service, or releases you.

When she is 8 years old, her grace manifests itself in the form of killing a man when he tries to take advantage of her. It is understood that her grace is killing. The king, of course, recognizes a potential for power that he didn't have before and enlists her in his service. She becomes his thug and kills, maims, or hurts anyone who has displeased the king. Though she refuses to kill unless necessary.

During her first years with the king, she is feared by all in the kingdom, but also realizes she can use her talent to help people get out of predicaments they are in when they can't defend themselves. She forms up a council, without the knowledge of the king, to find situations where she can help.

During one of her excursions for the council, rescuing an old man from a prison, she runs across another graceling named Po who can use a sword almost as well as her. He ends up knocking him out and escaping with her mission intact. He turns up at her king's court looking for the old man, who turns out to be his grandfather.

One day, she is called upon to hurt someone who has disobeyed the king, but realizes that this is a circumstance where she should be helping instead of hindering. She makes the decision to separate herself from the king and begins working with Po to figure out who wanted to harm the grandfather. As they work together, they fall in love (of course), and begin to understand how to work together. And both of their graces are not as they seem.

Comments

The book is very well told and has some great opportunities for discussion with youth. The story is mostly about youth who have potential/talents/graces that they don't understand. Moreover, about youth that don't understand how they fit into the world with the gifts they have been given. As the book progresses, both Katsa and Po realize the potential of who they are and are able to take graces that are thought to be monstrous and turn them into great value for good. It is all about taking responsibility for your life even when you think the life you have is unfair, hard, or poor. By taking control of your life, rather than blaming circumstances or others, you find the true ability to make a difference in the world.

Note: there is one scene that is a sex scene where you know they are having intercourse and the feelings during the act are expressed while occurring, but nothing explicit is described. In movies, it might be analogous to hearing sounds in the bedroom and knowing what is happening, but not actually seeing it. I was close to putting the book down, and decided against it. If you are going to have your youth read this, please review the book first to see what you think.

Friday, June 25, 2010

Soprano Sorceress

The Soprano Sorceress (Spellsong Cycle Series #1) by L. E. Modesitt Jr.: Book Cover

Published Information

Author: L. E. Modesitt Jr.
Series: The Spellsong Cycle #1
Published: Jan 1998
Genre: Fantasy
Pages: 672

Ratings

Violence: PG-13 (War violence, people burned to death)
Sexual Content: PG
Language: PG-13 (B-word is common, one f-bomb)
Reading Age: Young adult
Buy Recommend: Borrow (Story is ok, if like singing, fun story)
Overall Rating: 5 out of 10 (Enjoyable, but too long)

Plot Summary

Anna Marshal is a soprano from Iowa who is just passing her hay-day in opera singing and is slowly being pushed aside at the university where she teaches. Her life is not the best and she makes a wish that she were somewhere else. At that moment, a minor sorceress in a world called Erde is attempting to conjure a sorceress to help her in her world. Anna is the one that is magically summoned to Erde.

Erde is a world ruled by magic. And that magic is controlled by singing. When Anna arrives, many of the local rulers notice, through magical means, her appearance and recognize that she must be very powerful. As some of these leaders begin to approach her, either to garner her support or assasinate her, she realizes she needs to figure out how the magic works and develop her skills, or she will find her life ending sooner than expected. Once she understands her skills, she must decide who she will endorse and support, if any one... and how much she trusts them.

Comments

A couple of major themes in this book: power should only be held by those that don't want it, and sometimes the best intentions still cause problems.

On earth, she went through a messy divorce, dealt with politics in the university, and suffered through the death of one of her children. In essence, she has had to deal with a lot more that most should, and she has been toughened from the experience. When she arrives, because she is a woman, people treat her with disdain and as an object to be dismissed or mocked. In order to gain most people's respect, she has to resort to violence through magic. Though she is able to gain respect and support through force, she feels it shouldn't work that way. Throughout the book she works to change the culture where ever she can so that women, specifically, and anyone else that is in a lower class, are treated with equity and respect.

Additionally, she finds some of her changes cause unexpected problems. For example, at one point she uses magic to force a man to leave her alone by means of a spell that repels him anytime she is near. Unfortunately, he starts getting angry and takes out his anger on his wife for letting Anna stay with them. The point of the author, though, is not to avoid changes, but rather recognize that when changes occur there will be consequenses. Are the changes worth the consequenses? That is the question we should ask.

Overall, I enjoyed the plot. The plot was consistent and easy to follow, though a little predictable. One minor annoyance of mine was that the author used the first person present whenever someone other than the main character was running the storyline. For example, when the author showed us councils from the leaders looking for Anna, they would say things like "the speaker looks up and says 'Yo.' He thinks this is cool. He sits down" rather than the normal voice. Not a big deal but I didn't care for it.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Half-moon Investigations

Half-Moon Investigations by Eoin Colfer: Book Cover

Published Information

Author: Eoin Colfer
Published: April 2006
Genre: Adventure
Pages: 304

Ratings

Violence: PG
Sexual Content: G
Language: PG
Reading Age: Junior High
Buy Recommend: Paperback
Overall Rating: 5 out of 10

Plot Summary

Fletcher Moon is a 12 year old kid who has taken note of details all his life. It has enabled him to help people solve "mysteries" that they couldn't figure out. Fletcher decided to make it official, so, with the use of his father's birth certificate, he was able to register for an online detective course. He graduated first in his class and has the badge to prove it.

But now, he is forced to work with people he would normally consider criminals in order to clear his own name of a crime he was framed for, as well as stop a conspiracy that threatens to bring down boys and adults across the school playground.

Comments

As mentioned above, this book targets children in junior high, so ages 10-13 as the initial demographic. However, the book is written in your standard "gum-shoe" style that will give adults a kick as well. So while I wouldn't recommend this book to an adult as something that they would normally pick up and read, if you like reading books with your children (either aloud or just keeping pace with them), then this is the book for you. Your children and youth will love it (so long as they like adventure type books) and you will find it humorous.

It does deal with issues such as handling feeling like an outcast, overcoming stereotypes and first impressions, as well as differences in families (criminal family, versus average joe family, versus extremely rich). All in all, great, light entertainment for adults and a good platform to discuss some interesting topics with children.